By Moses Cho, Founder, DreamBridge Academy. Updated November 2026. About 9 minutes.
The bottom line: If your student is aiming at highly selective colleges, plan to test, and plan to test well. A strong SAT or ACT score is once again a standard part of a complete application at many of the most selective universities, including UT Austin, and more of them will require scores for students entering in fall 2028 and 2029. Treat “test-optional” as a decision to make deliberately, school by school, after the score is in hand, not as permission to skip preparation. Prepare seriously once, aim to finish testing by the end of junior year, and then submit wherever the score strengthens the file.
The test-optional era has not ended, but it has split in two. Most colleges remain optional. The most selective universities, however, have been moving steadily back toward requirements, and families who planned around the policies of a few years ago are often working from an outdated map. According to the Common App’s 2025-26 data, score reporters outnumbered non-reporters for the first time since 2019-20, which tells you how applicants themselves have responded.
Required for this cycle:
Optional this cycle, but changing: Princeton, Columbia, and Notre Dame are optional for fall 2027 entry and will require scores for fall 2028 entry. Vanderbilt is optional through fall 2028 entry and will require scores for fall 2029. Texas A&M is optional for fall 2027, and a requirement for 2028 has been proposed but is not final.
Optional with no announced change: Duke remains test-optional for the 2026-2027 cycle, and Northwestern has been test-optional in recent cycles. The University of California system remains test-free and does not consider scores in admission. Policies continue to shift, so confirm each one on the college’s own admissions site before your student finalizes a plan.
A test score is never read in isolation. Readers place it next to the transcript and the high school’s profile and ask a simple question: does this score confirm what the grades suggest? A student with top grades in the most demanding courses at their school and a score inside or above the college’s typical range presents a coherent, credible picture. That coherence is what readers are looking for.
Scores carry particular weight in three situations. First, at schools with wide variation in grading, a score gives readers a common reference point, which is one reason several universities have cited when reinstating requirements. Second, for students applying to engineering, computer science, economics, or other quantitative fields, the math section functions as evidence of readiness for the coursework, and readers notice an imbalance between a strong verbal score and a modest math score in an aspiring engineer. Third, for students from high schools that send few applicants to a given college, a strong score helps a reader calibrate an unfamiliar transcript.
What quietly hurts an applicant is a mismatch. A score well below the college’s range sitting next to a near-perfect GPA invites the reader to wonder about grade inflation or test readiness. Conversely, a very high score paired with a light course load raises the question of why the student did not challenge themselves. A score also cannot rescue an application that lacks rigor, depth of involvement, or a clear voice in the essays. Think of it as a credential that opens the door to a full reading, not the reason a reader says yes.
Our rule is direct: submit when the score sits at or above the middle 50% range the college reports in its Common Data Set (section C9). Below that range, the rest of the application will usually speak more clearly without it. Test-optional colleges state that they do not penalize students who apply without scores, and that is generally true in the narrow sense. But a student who withholds a score is asking the transcript, recommendations, and essays to carry all of the academic evidence, so those pieces must be unusually strong.
Apply the rule school by school, not once for the whole list. The same score can be a clear asset at one university and a liability at another. A student might send scores to a strong target school where the score sits near the top of its range and withhold them from a reach school where the score falls in the lower part of the range. That is a legitimate and common strategy, and readers do not see where else a student did or did not submit.
When the decision is close, weigh the rest of the file. A student with an upward grade trend, demanding coursework, and strong teacher recommendations can more comfortably apply without a borderline score. A student whose transcript has a weak semester or whose school is unfamiliar to the college should lean toward submitting a score that is solidly in range, because it supplies reassurance the transcript alone cannot.
Finally, for any college on the list that requires testing, the question is settled. If even one required-test school is on the list, your student needs a competitive score, and the plan should be built around that fact.
The strongest testing plans are short, focused, and finished early. Long, open-ended test preparation drains time from coursework and activities during the most important academic year, so we advise families to treat testing as a defined project with a clear end.
Have your student take a full, timed practice test of both the SAT and the ACT. Colleges that require testing accept either equally, so the choice should rest on which format suits your student’s pacing and strengths. Commit to one test and do not switch midstream without a strong reason.
Begin structured preparation early in the year and register for a first official sitting in winter or early spring. For the current junior class, the remaining SAT dates are March 6, May 1, and June 5, 2027, and the ACT is offered February 27, April 10, June 12, and July 10, 2027. Plan for at least two sittings, spaced far enough apart to allow targeted work on weak areas in between. The goal is to have a final score before senior year begins.
A summer sitting is a reasonable final attempt for students who are close to their goal. Senior fall should be devoted to essays and applications. For current seniors, the December 5, 2026 SAT and December 12, 2026 ACT can still help for some Regular Decision deadlines, but check whether each college will accept December scores before registering.
For Texas families, testing is no longer optional at the flagship. UT Austin has required scores since fall 2025 entry and accepts the SAT, ACT, or CLT. Importantly, UT uses the highest single sitting rather than superscoring across dates, which changes how a student should approach multiple attempts: each sitting needs to be a complete, well-prepared performance, not a chance to improve one section at a time. For a full view of how UT reads applications, see our guide on how to get into UT Austin from Dallas.
Texas A&M remains optional for fall 2027, with a requirement for 2028 proposed but not final. Families with younger students should prepare as though the requirement will take effect. A student who has a strong score in hand loses nothing if the policy stays optional.
Many DFW high schools in McKinney, Frisco, Plano, and Prosper are large and academically deep, which means class rank can be fiercely competitive and grade differences between strong students are often small. In that environment, a score is one of the few measures that lets a student stand apart from classmates with nearly identical transcripts. It also matters for students at schools that do not rank, or that send relatively few graduates to a particular out-of-state university, where a score helps readers interpret the record. Use the PSAT in the fall of junior year as a serious rehearsal: it previews SAT readiness, and a strong performance can lead to National Merit recognition.
The most common testing mistakes we see are not about ability. They are about planning and judgment.
Is the SAT or the ACT better? Neither is better in the eyes of admissions offices. Colleges that require testing accept either test equally and do not prefer one. Have your student take a full, timed practice test of each, compare the results and how the experience felt, and prepare for the better fit. The best test is the one your student can prepare for efficiently and perform on consistently.
Do colleges superscore? Many do, but not all. Some combine the best section scores across dates, while others, including UT Austin, use the highest single sitting. Check each college’s policy before planning additional attempts, because it affects whether a retake should focus on one section or the whole test. When the list includes both kinds of schools, prepare for each sitting as a complete performance.
Why are colleges bringing tests back? Several universities have said that scores help them identify talented students, including those from under-resourced high schools, more accurately than grades alone. Grading standards vary widely from school to school, and a common measure helps readers compare students fairly. For applicants, the practical takeaway is that a strong score is evidence readers value, not a box to check.
My student’s score is just below a college’s middle 50% range. Should we submit it? At a test-optional school, usually not. A score near the bottom of the range rarely helps, and the rest of the application can make the case without it. If the college requires testing, the better path is another well-prepared sitting if time allows. Either way, the decision should be made per school, not once for the whole list.
How does testing fit with an early application? For a November deadline, your student will want final scores before senior year, or at the latest from an early fall sitting. That is one more reason to finish testing by the end of junior year. Our guide to Early Decision vs. Early Action covers how to sequence an early plan.
Testing strategy is not a single decision. It depends on which colleges are on the list, how the transcript reads, and how much time remains before deadlines. Moses Cho personally reviews every DreamBridge student’s plan, and we can help your family decide which test to take, when to stop, and where to submit. Schedule a complimentary 30-minute consultation to build a testing plan that fits your student’s list and timeline.
Have a question about this topic or your student's situation? Send it privately below. Moses reads every question and replies personally by email. Please do not include your student's full name or other private details.
Thank you. Your question has been received, and Moses will reply to you personally by email.
Something went wrong. Please email info@dreambridgeacademy.com instead.