By Moses Cho, Founder, DreamBridge Academy. Updated November 2026. About 9 minutes.
The bottom line: Selective colleges reward depth, initiative, and impact, not volume. Help your student choose two or three commitments and pursue them for years, taking on more responsibility as they go. A passion project is worth doing only if it grows from a genuine interest and produces something real that other people can see or use. Do not buy prestige: expensive summer programs, on their own, do not improve a student’s chances, and admissions offices say so plainly.
Admissions readers are not counting activities. They are trying to understand how a student spends their time when no one requires it, and what that says about the person who will arrive on campus. The questions in their minds are simple. What does this student care about? What did they do with the opportunities available to them? Did they grow, take responsibility, and make something better?
Selective colleges have been unusually direct about this. MIT tells applicants not to worry about having many activities and to focus on the few things that genuinely excite them, and it judges what students did with the opportunities they had. Stanford notes that exceptional depth in one or two activities can show real passion, and that work and family responsibilities count as much as any other activity. Yale’s admissions podcast, in a February 2025 episode, dismissed the ideas that applicants need more of everything, that they must have a single “spike,” or that founding an organization is inherently more impressive than participating in one.
Activities also matter in proportion. In NACAC’s fall 2023 survey, only 6.5% of colleges rated extracurriculars as considerably important, while 44.3% rated them moderately important. Grades and rigor come first. But at selective colleges, where most applicants have strong transcripts, activities and the character they reveal often help decide close cases.
What quietly hurts an applicant is a list that looks assembled rather than lived: many brief memberships, titles without substance, or a sudden burst of activity in junior year that reads as resume-building. Readers have seen thousands of these lists, and they recognize the pattern quickly.
The strongest activity profiles share a structure. A student finds something they care about, stays with it, and takes on more responsibility each year. That arc, from participant to contributor to leader or builder, is what readers remember.
We advise families to think of activities in three tiers. The first tier is the student’s core commitment, the one or two activities that receive the most time and where the student has the most to show. The second tier supports the core: related activities that add depth or show another side of the same interest. The third tier is everything else, including jobs, family responsibilities, and activities pursued simply for enjoyment. All three tiers belong on the application, but the first tier should be unmistakable.
Responsibility can take many forms. Leadership does not have to mean a title. A student who trains new members, rebuilds a club’s process, organizes a community event, or quietly becomes the person everyone relies on is showing leadership. Readers value that as much as an elected position, and often more.
Consistency counts. Several years in the same orchestra, lab, team, or volunteer role shows commitment that cannot be manufactured in a single summer. If your student wants to change direction, that is fine, but the new path should be pursued with the same seriousness.
Context matters. A student at a large DFW high school with dozens of clubs is read differently from a student at a small school with few options. Admissions readers look at what was available. Use what your student’s school and community actually offer, rather than chasing activities that do not fit.
A passion project is an independent effort that a student initiates and drives. Done well, it is one of the clearest ways to show initiative. Done poorly, it reads as a credential purchased for the application.
It grows from a real interest. The best projects begin with a question or a problem the student already cares about. A student fascinated by local water quality might start testing samples and sharing results with a city council. A student who loves history might record oral histories from older relatives and neighbors. The idea does not have to be grand; it has to be genuine.
It produces something visible. Strong projects have results someone else can see: a piece of research, a tool people use, a program that served real people, a body of creative work, or a written record. Readers want evidence, not intentions.
It connects to the rest of the application. Coursework, the intended major, the personal essay, and recommendations should reinforce the same picture of the student. A project in computational biology is more convincing when the transcript shows advanced biology and math and a teacher can speak to the student’s curiosity.
It shows growth over time. Readers notice when a project develops, attracts collaborators, or changes direction based on what the student learned. Setbacks honestly described are part of that growth.
What to avoid: projects designed by adults, projects with impressive names and little substance, and anything a student cannot discuss in detail. If your student could not explain the project confidently in an interview, it does not belong at the center of the application.
Families often ask which summer program will help most. Our answer is that the program’s name matters far less than what the student does and why.
Many pre-college programs on famous campuses are open to anyone who can pay. Stanford says attending its Summer Session does not increase a student’s chances of admission to Stanford. Harvard states that its pre-college program does not assure admission to Harvard College. MIT notes that most summer programs admit nearly everyone who can pay the tuition, and that there is no right or wrong way to spend a summer. These programs can be enjoyable and educational, and there is nothing wrong with attending one for its own sake. But they are not a strategy.
Summers that do strengthen an application tend to share a quality: the student does something substantive and can describe it with specifics. That might be a job, a family responsibility, independent research, a creative project, or sustained service. Selective, merit-based programs that admit students competitively are a different category and can carry meaning, but they are one option among many.
Practical guidance:
Strong activities can be undersold by weak descriptions. The Common App’s activities section has room for 10 activities, each with a 150-character description and a 50-character position title, plus a separate section for up to 5 honors. According to Common App’s materials for 2026-27, the section is renamed “Activities and experiences,” and the position field is now optional. That change is a useful reminder that the description, not the title, carries the weight.
Order by significance. List the most meaningful activities first. Readers give the most attention to the top of the list.
Use the 150 characters for action and impact. Start with strong verbs. Say what your student did and what changed because of it. “Member of robotics club” says nothing. “Redesigned team’s drivetrain; trained new members in CAD; team reached state finals” says a great deal.
Use numbers only when they are honest and meaningful. Hours per week, people served, funds raised, or concrete results help readers understand scale. Never inflate them.
Leave slots empty rather than padding. A shorter list of substantial activities is stronger than a full one that includes filler. Readers notice padding, and it dilutes the strongest entries.
Include work and family responsibilities. Caring for siblings, working in a family business, or holding a part-time job belongs here and is read with respect.
Collecting rather than committing. Joining many clubs in ninth and tenth grade is natural exploration. Carrying all of them into the application without narrowing is a mistake.
Starting a project too late. A project launched the summer before senior year rarely has time to show depth or results. Readers can see the dates.
Chasing a title. Founding a club or nonprofit is not inherently more impressive than contributing deeply to an existing one. Yale’s admissions office has said exactly that.
Letting adults drive the work. Projects that parents or hired professionals design and run do not reflect the student, and readers often sense it. Authenticity is the point. Parents can help with logistics, introductions, and encouragement; the ideas and the work must be the student’s.
Inconsistent story. An activity list pointing in one direction, an essay in another, and a stated major in a third makes the application harder to read. Not everything must align, but the core should be coherent.
Neglecting grades for activities. No activity compensates for a declining transcript. Protect academic performance first, and scale back commitments during heavy exam periods rather than letting both suffer.
Ninth grade. Explore. Try several activities and pay attention to which ones your student returns to without prompting. Keep a simple record of hours, roles, and accomplishments; it will be valuable later.
Tenth grade. Narrow to two or three commitments. Look for growing responsibility. If a passion project is appealing, this is the ideal time to begin, so it has room to grow. Our timeline by grade explains how activities fit with coursework and testing.
Eleventh grade. Deepen rather than add. Take on leadership or a larger role in existing commitments, and develop the project into something with visible results. Avoid starting many new activities in the most demanding academic year.
Summer before twelfth grade. Complete or extend the project, write strong activity descriptions, and look for ways the essay can reveal the thinking behind the work without simply restating it. Our guide to the Common App essay prompts can help.
Twelfth grade. Stay engaged. Readers notice when commitments end abruptly once applications are submitted. If your student is deferred or waitlisted, a meaningful update on continued work can be a useful part of a thoughtful response, so keep building through the spring. The aim throughout is a record your student can speak about with pride and in detail.
Does my student need a nonprofit or a startup? No. Yale’s admissions office has said there is nothing inherently special about creating something rather than participating in it. Depth, contribution, and genuine interest matter far more than the label. A student who contributes meaningfully to an existing organization for years is often more compelling than one who founded something that never grew.
Do part-time jobs count? Yes. Stanford and MIT both treat work and family responsibilities as meaningful activities. A job shows reliability, maturity, and time management, and many readers value it highly. List it with the same care as any other activity, including hours and responsibilities.
When should a passion project begin? Ideally in ninth or tenth grade, so it has time to grow and produce results. A project started in the summer before senior year rarely has time to show depth. If your student is older, it is still worth pursuing a genuine interest, but present it honestly as a recent effort rather than overstating its scope.
Does my student need a “spike”? Not necessarily. Yale’s admissions podcast has pushed back on the idea that applicants must have a single, narrow area of distinction. What matters is genuine engagement and growth. Some students have one dominant interest; others have two or three related ones. Either can be compelling if pursued with depth.
How should we handle activities that ended or changed? List them honestly with accurate dates. Readers understand that students change direction as they discover new interests. What matters is that the student pursued each commitment seriously and that the most significant activities show sustained effort.
The right activities are the ones that reflect who your student is and where they want to go. We help students identify genuine interests, build commitments with real depth, and present that work clearly and honestly. If you would like a thoughtful plan for your student’s activities, Schedule a complimentary 30-minute consultation.
Have a question about this topic or your student's situation? Send it privately below. Moses reads every question and replies personally by email. Please do not include your student's full name or other private details.
Thank you. Your question has been received, and Moses will reply to you personally by email.
Something went wrong. Please email info@dreambridgeacademy.com instead.